TCI Commentary:
The international reach of the Public Consultation phenomenon continues, with news that fracking has given rise to a major dispute about a development in the Shannon estuary on the south-west coast of Ireland. ( See article below)
Friends of the Irish Environment (FIE) has launched a case against the state authorities, seeking a full Environment Impact Assessment and a subsequent Public Consultation, asserting wider interests than just a local planning decision, and drawing in the Paris Agreement on Climate Change; no doubt the Aarhus Convention will also be cited and a claim lodged there.
Ireland lost its first Aarhus case, since it signed up in 2012, earlier this year in July, about the failure to provide sufficient information to communities, in relation to a quarry development in Co Meath.
With effective global comms and swift internet sharing, lobbies like this can network, share and mobilise with minimum fuss, cost or obstruction; in turn, this helps implement and test these lesser-known international treaties and agreements, in real-time through real local issues being explored in specialists forums designed for the purpose.
tCI’s international reach is being extended, as we discover common issues in every jurisdiction in which we operate or are invited to observe.
Article:
The State has been warned it cannot approve the proposed liquefied natural gas facility in the Shannon estuary as a “project of common interest” without a strategic environmental assessment and public consultation. The warning was issued by Friends of the Irish Environment (FIE), whose legal challenge to the extension of time for construction of the Shannon plant has been referred by the High Court to the European Court of Justice for advice.
The Shannon development, proposed by US company New Fortress Energy, is designed to import and process shale gas extracted through fracking. Projects of common interest (PCIs) are key cross-border infrastructure projects linking energy systems in EU countries to enable energy policy, including long-term decarbonisation, in accordance with the Paris climate change agreement.
Environmental permits
The Government currently plans to support placing the Shannon facility on the list of PCIs, which will ensure it receives highest priority in terms of State support. An EU meeting next month will finalise the list.
PCIs are considered to be projects with “imperative reasons of overriding public interest”, allowing them accelerated planning and environmental permits.
In a letter to Minister for Climate Action Richard Bruton, Friends of the Irish Environment said it is “extremely concerned” that the project will involve importation of fracked gas, “has the potential to lock in hydrocarbon infrastructure without any strategic assessment at a national level” and will harm protected habitats. According to FIE, the proposed terminal and Ireland’s access to the global liquefied natural gas market were not mentioned in the key climate plans. Nor was it “screened” to determine if a strategic environmental assessment was necessary.
FIE said it was “unable to find any substantive information such as a draft plan; an environmental report, a screening report, Natura impact assessment or any notices in relation to the approval procedure”.
‘Crisis’
FIE Director Tony Lowes said, “the distance between the Minister’s words and his deeds grows exponentially as the climate crisis deepens”. More than 44 TDs have signed a Dáil motion calling for the Government to drop its support for gas terminals that would import fracked gas from the United States. People Before Profit TD Bríd Smith said cross-party support demonstrated serious concern with Government policy on climate. “Continuing support for fracked gas imports into Ireland and Europe is criminally irresponsible and shows utter disregard for the climate movement and the school children’s strikes.”
Article originally appeared on The Irish Times
The Institute cannot confirm the accuracy of this story or confirm that it presents a balanced view. If you feel this is inaccurate, we would welcome your perspective and evidence that this is the case.
