Skip to content

Pre-determination – School governors face legal challenge

Yarmouth Primary School governors have been threatened with legal action by campaigners fighting to save the school.

A letter has been sent to the chair of governors Carla Bradshaw by solicitors acting on behalf of Keep Yarmouth School in Yarmouth campaigners — calling on the governing body to abandon the plans or face a judicial review.

It argues a consultation on the proposals, which closes on Friday, was ‘legally flawed’ because governors had already decided to close the school before asking the public for their views.

The news comes days after the Isle of Wight Council released its latest report on plans to reduce the number of surplus school places in the West Wight.

Set to go before council cabinet on Thursday, the report recommends the closure of All Saints CE Primary School in Freshwater, providing the Yarmouth governors support moving the school to the Freshwater site.

The legal letter states: “Proper consultation was particularly important given that the council had already, unlawfully and unfairly, purported to exercise a power to affect the proposed transfer and those affected were distrustful of the council. The decision here is not genuinely taken ‘in principle’, it is not a ‘pre-disposition’ but is ‘predetermined’ and constitutes the surrender by the governors of its judgement by having a closed mind and failing to apply it to the task. The consultation now being carried out cannot satisfy the standard and fundamental public law requirement.”

Ms Bradshaw said it would be inappropriate to comment on behalf of the governors while the decision was pending.

The governors’ decision is due to be made next Monday, January 13, which could see the closure of All Saints at the end of the current school year.

If the governors do not consent to relocating the school, the council could either keep All Saints open and close Yarmouth, or close both schools and build a new academy instead.

A spokesperson for the Keep Yarmouth School in Yarmouth campaign said: “The solicitor’s letter warns the governors they have prejudged the issue and if they continue with their proposal we will take legal action to stop them. Parents have a legal right to choose where they send their children, and many choose to send them to Yarmouth which is a small caring school. This right will be taken away by the governors if we do not defend it.”

An Isle of Wight Council spokesperson said the authority had no comment to make at this time.


Article originally appeared on Isle of Wight county press

The Institute cannot confirm the accuracy of this story or confirm that it presents a balanced view. If you feel this is inaccurate, we would welcome your perspective and evidence that this is the case.

Scroll To Top