Scottish Council lose JR against Scottish Gov

TCI Comment

An interesting little case here, which, although it does not majorly advance or develop the extant law, does highlight the importance of accuracy in consultation documents. The failure to correct background mathematics to come up with figures to be put in consultation documents here rendered the decision vulnerable to call in, as did the subsequent disputes over Council assumptions about ownership and suitability of certain other facilities. A reminder to make sure when you prepare your consultation documents that the information contained within is correct, and not merely ‘arguable’. Despite the fact that this consultation process had been a long one, the mistakes made by the consultor ultimately lead to the failure of their challenge to the call-in decision. Another interesting point from this case relates to the importance of respecting any statutory requirements for information. In this case, the local authority was required in its proposal paper to address any efforts they had made to try and tackle falling roll numbers before deciding that they needed to make changes. Their failure to adequately do so was another factor in the Court deciding that the call-in decision by the ministers was valid. Although this is a very case specific stipulation, consultors more generally should always be aware of the context of their consultations, and any requirements that might apply even before the start of the consultation process.

Perth and Kinross Council has failed in a legal bid to prevent the Scottish Government from reviewing a school closure decision.

The court of session has ruled that Holyrood can re-examine the fate of Abernyte Primary, which is set to shut permanently at the end of this term. Pupils are due to transfer to Inchture Primary, three miles away across the A90, after the summer.

The council took legal action after the decision was called in by government ministers last summer. It followed a knife-edge vote by the local authority’s lifelong learning committee to axe the school, despite protests from local residents.

Now, it will be up to the independent School Closure Review panel to decide whether or not to uphold the Carse of Gowrie school’s impending closure. It will be only the fourth decision to be made by the Edinburgh-based panel.

A Perth and Kinross Council spokesperson said: “We have been made aware of the decision of the court, which we acknowledge, and will now proceed with the next steps in the process and provide the School Closure Review panel with the information requested.”

A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “We welcome the outcome of the judicial review, and will consider the detail of the judgement in due course.”

Perth and North Perthshire MP Pete Wishart has criticised the local authority for the legal move. He said: “This has been an unnecessary court case paid for by local taxpayers. The case has served only to waste public money in an attempt to remove the legal right of the school community at Abernyte to independent consideration of their case to keep their school open. There is no length that the council has not been prepared to go to in their attempt to close Abernyte Primary School. Perth and Kinross Council must now disclose how much this cost the public here and they must immediately confirm that Abernyte School will not close as it was scheduled to.”

Education Secretary John Swinney relinquished any say he might have had over the case due to a conflict of interest as a local representative. He said he was satisfied with Lady Wise’s verdict.

He added: “I am glad the decision of the Scottish Government to exercise that legal right for the people of Abernyte has been vindicated at the Court of Session.”

 

Article originally appeared on The Courier

The Institute cannot confirm the accuracy of this story or confirm that it presents a balanced view. If you feel this is inaccurate we would welcome your perspective and evidence that this is the case.

Shopping Basket
Scroll to Top

Your membership questions answered

View our frequently asked questions or contact our dedicated account manager for further support.

You can reset your password here. If you’re still having issues, please send us a message below.

We have many ways you can pay for your membership.

  • Credit card
  • Online
  • Invoice
  • PO
  • Monthly

You can renew/upgrade your membership here.

To find out more, send us a message below.

You will receive a reminder email from our dedicated membership account manager 4 weeks before your renewal date. This email will contain all the information you need to renew.

You can also renew your membership online here.

You can update your contact details here. Alternatively, please send a message to our membership account manager below.

Please send a message to our membership account manager below. 

Still need support?

Our dedicated Membership Account Manager is on
hand to assist with any questions you might have.

Request a callback

Leave a message and our team will call you back

"*" indicates required fields

Name*

Send us a message

We’ll be in touch with you soon.

Name(Required)
Email(Required)