A public body that clearly promises to consult, or consults so consistently that people come to expect it, can create a legal duty it never intended to take on. This article explains what counts as a promise, how past practice can have the same effect, and why every commitment to consult needs managing as carefully as the consultation itself.
What is a legitimate expectation of consultation?
A legitimate expectation of consultation is a legal protection, enforced through judicial review (a court’s check on whether a public body acted lawfully), that arises when a public body’s words or conduct lead people reasonably to expect they will be consulted. It can come from a clear promise or from an established practice, even where no law requires consultation.
There is no general duty on public bodies to consult before every decision. In England and Wales, the common law (the law developed by judges rather than Parliament) recognises three routes beyond legislation: a promise to consult, an established practice of consulting and, exceptionally, conspicuous unfairness, meaning that proceeding without it would be plainly unfair.
High Court judge Mr Justice Fordham summarised these routes in his December 2025 speech. No statute is needed for a duty to arise. This article concentrates on the first two, which a body controls through what it says and does.
What counts as a promise to consult?
A promise only creates a legal expectation if what was said is clear, open to only one reasonable reading, and not hedged by conditions that limit it. It does not have to sit in a consultation document. In R (Mitchell) v Secretary of State for Justice [2021], it sat in the Government’s 2018 Victims Strategy, a general policy document.
The claimant, Kim Mitchell, had been refused criminal injuries compensation because of an unspent conviction (meaning one that still counts on a person’s record). The Strategy had indicated that the Government would consult on further changes to the compensation scheme, including revising that exclusion rule.
The Government’s 2020 review of the compensation scheme consulted without asking a specific question about the rule. The High Court held that the Strategy had created a legitimate expectation, that the expectation had not been met, and ordered a consultation, which the Government then held in 2022.
The lesson is that wording and context decide the question. A statement that an authority will consult before deciding whether to implement a defined proposal identifies a process and a decision point. A stated ambition to involve communities does not necessarily commit an authority to consult on every later decision. Broad wording should never be assumed harmless.
Can past practice create a duty to consult?
Yes. A settled practice of consulting can bind a public body as a promise can, even if nobody ever promised it. In Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985], the House of Lords (then the UK’s highest court) recognised that a legitimate expectation can arise from a promise or from a regular practice.
The Government had long consulted civil service unions before changing terms of employment at Government Communications Headquarters, the national intelligence and security agency. That history gave the unions a genuine expectation of being consulted. The Lords accepted it, but held that national security justified acting without consultation.
Practice creates the expectation, and a strong competing interest can still outweigh it. The test is consistency: a handful of earlier consultations does not by itself create a binding practice, and a body that consults on some decisions but not others should be able to explain the difference.
If one team within an organisation has always consulted residents on a certain kind of change and another has not, nobody has decided what the organisation’s practice is, yet those affected may reasonably see a pattern and expect consultation next time.
What should decision makers do about commitments to consult?
The first difficulty is knowing what has been promised. A promise can be made by one team and inherited by another, whether in a committee report, a public meeting or an assurance to an affected group. The team delivering the consultation may meet it only when options have narrowed. Losing track of a promise is a governance failure, and it is avoidable.
The second is knowing what the promise covers. A promise to consult on whether to adopt a policy is not automatically a promise to consult on its detail, and a promise to consult one group does not extend to the whole public. In Mitchell, a general consultation did not satisfy a promise to consult on one specific rule.
The third is resisting the urge to drop it. A promise does not lapse because consultation has become expensive, slow or politically unwelcome. Courts weigh an expectation against competing public interests, as the Lords did, but inconvenience is not one of them. Any reason for departing from it must stand up, and be examined before the decision is made.
Before promising to consult, an organisation should know what decision remains open, what process it can deliver, who will take part and whether the wording is appropriately qualified. Afterwards, it should be able to trace the commitment when the decision comes forward.
Once a duty exists, the consultation delivering it must be fair, which is where the Gunning principles, the legal test for fair public consultation, apply. The Cabinet Office’s Consultation Principles have no legal force but set a practical standard, including consulting while policy is still forming and allowing proportionate time to respond.
None of this is an argument against making promises. Clear commitments build accountability and support meaningful engagement. They should simply be deliberate rather than accidental.
How tCI Can Help
Organisation Wide Learning Hub Access
Equip your entire team with professional consultation skills through one platform. Self paced courses, live virtual classrooms, practical toolkits and expert resources that build a shared baseline of competence across your organisation. Trusted by councils, NHS bodies and regulators nationwide.
Bespoke Training Workshops
Training that works with your real projects, not hypothetical scenarios. Sector tailored sessions help teams apply good practice to live challenges: sharpening consultation documents, building defensible codebooks, strengthening equality analyses. Half day or full day workshops for health, local government, planning and public service teams.
Coaching for Complex or High Risk Consultations
Expert guidance when the stakes are highest. One to one and small group coaching for senior officers navigating legally exposed or politically contentious decisions. Strengthen your judgement on proportionality, evidence standards and challenge management. Essential for organisations that may face judicial review risk or major service changes.
Whether you’re preparing for a high stakes service change, building long term consultation capability, or need confidence that your evidence approach will stand up to scrutiny, we can help.
Contact tCI: hello@consultationinstitute.org.